Puul's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Till There Was You]

Not bad at all

The guitar is played very well, the melody is good, but I miss some other instruments. Besides, the ending is a little too well... hard. It just stops at 1:05. Please keep workin on this, it could become a really great song!

[Plastic space]

Alright...

I´ll try some constructive criticism, but this will be a kind of hard for me (I´m german, still learning how to speak english...). Well, alright^^

I think all in all this is quite a good first submission and at least better than the demo ;) I like the beginning very much, but in my opinion those shrill noises that start at 0:30 are a bit... well, too shrill^^ Even if the tune is okay, nothing special, bt okay. The beat is good and fit´s to the rest of the music.
It´s good, but all in all a little to strange for me.
So:
3/5
6/10

But keep on making music, I guess this is better, than my first submission xD

Well, I hope you understand what I wanted to say ;)

Puul

Webzex responds:

Thank you very much pull ,will do :)

[DJ VeXy - Starlight]

Feel like somewhere in space

Nice song. I like the intro, I can really imagine such an "somewhere-in-space-scene". The part at 1:02 is good too, but not as much as the first part. However, all in all a great track. I hope you´ll do something like this again ;)

[The Final Kingdom]

Nice tune

Really!
5/5
10/10
I added it to my favs.
Still got something to say, but I don´t know how^^ Why the hell is NG in english? xD
However, great song ;)

Seattlesith7 responds:

Thanks for the review. Glad you liked it, and thanks for the add to your favorites. I try my best. But I no idea what you're talking about with NG being in English. Still, thanks again, and don't forget to check some of my other work out.

[_-={Day of War}=-_]

Epic!

Great piece of music!
I drawed a picture to this: Eveyrthing´s dark, dead bodies and broken stuff everywhere. But there´s a light from heaven. A new hope awakes, the hero is there...
Well... maybe a little strange, but that´s what I imagined while listining to this song, so I had to draw it.^^
Hope you know what I mean, I still learn how to speak english ;)

[Memories from the past]

Not bad at all

Well done, I like it especially the part at 0:34. I guess this guy had a nice past?
But all in all it´s a little to quiet, anyway, a good song ;)

[.:( Orion's Belt ):.]

Inspiration! Thanks!

This inspired me to draw a picture: A winter landscape, an old house on the right hand and an frozen tree on left. Great mountains in the background, soon it´s getting dark. And some lonely tracks in the snow, getting lost in the background.
At last i drawed an old, nearly broken sign post in the foreground "Orinon´s Belt" written on it.

Do I still have to say, that i like the song?^^

I hope you understand what i wrote, my english isn´t the best, i think^^

NickPerrin responds:

Yup, I understood just fine. That's awesome! Glad you enjoyed the track and took such inspiration from it in a way I never imagined. Thanks for the review

[container drums xD]

Interesting but...

the tune is really strange and sounds sometimes a little irregularly. Though this countainer sound at the beginning is really... well, interesting^^ Reminds me a bit on the beginning of "People are People" from Depeche Mode.

[FFX-2 Theme - Remake]

Really good theme, although...

I don´t know the original piece. But I like the Harmony of this song. Great pianoplay.

[(NUB)Enjoy The Silence]

my favorite song remixed! nice!

Rally awesome song, man! Well done! But I missed the voice later and at the beginning it was a little bit to quiet, i think. However, a great song

nubbinownz responds:

I didn't want to use the voice too much because I wanted it to be a cover more than a remix.